Broadway Dress Code: What to Wear to a Broadway Show
Wondering what the Broadway dress code is? Picking the perfect outfit can be tough. Follow these tips and you won’t be too over or underdressed at the theater.
Since I’ve seen pretty much every show that’s played on Broadway for almost a decade (many thanks to my eight years working in the industry), plus tons of theater (abroad and in New York) in my years as a travel writer, I have a very selective list of shows I’d want to pay to see again.
I also like to think that since I’ve seen 100s of Broadway shows, have worked for one of the top Broadway theatrical companies, and am a trained actress, I’ve got great taste when it comes to recommending shows to my friends.
Seeing a Broadway show while visiting NYC is a real treat, so the last thing you’d want is to pick the wrong show to splurge on because let’s face it, tickets are expensive these days!
I’ve created this rundown giving tips on some of the best shows on Broadway, as well as some of the most popular ones, in order to help you make the most out of your time visiting New York City!
And, if you’re stuck on what show to see between a couple, shoot me an e-mail. I’m always happy to give personalized theatrical advice!
Skip Ahead
Best Shows on Broadway for Families
Lion King
The Lion King has been running for over a decade and is still selling out most nights.
It’s one of the best shows on Broadway to take children to, especially since they’ve likely seen the film and will be mesmerized as the beloved characters come to life as giant puppets.
Truthfully, as an adult, I was blown away by the creativity of the show, though wouldn’t pay to sit through it again, unless I’m taking one of my nephews (which is happening soon – so I’ll update you on how the show’s looking almost a decade later).
If you want a theater experience without a noisy audience distracting you, head to another show.
Seating Tip: For the most magical experience, book central aisle seats in the orchestra. They’ll be a bit more expensive, but totally worth it for the first number (trust me!).
Run Time: 2 hours and 30 minutes, including one intermission.
Age Restrictions: No children under 2 will be allowed in the theater. This show is recommended for ages 6 and up, though my nephew saw the tour at age 2 and was instantly obsessed, so use your best judgment on if your child can sit silently during the full show.
Theater: Minskoff Theatre – 200 West 45th Street, New York, NY 10036
Aladdin
Aladdin makes the list purely because there’s limited options for families with kids, and it has a few delightful moments.
Compared to some of the other Disney shows I’ve caught over the years, I found this show to be the most disappointing Disney production.
The story line has changed a bit from the film, and it felt like they used their entire budget on the costumes, which are stunning, but didn’t put enough into building a truly magical set.
I don’t think it helps that Aladdin has always been one of my favorite Disney movies, so I had very high expectations going in, especially after how magical some of their other shows have been.
Seating Tip: Sit in the front mezzanine for this show. With all the fun choreography and a special “magic” moment or two during the show, you’ll have a much better view from this angle.
Run Time: 2 hours and 30 minutes, including one intermission.
Age Restrictions: Kids 2 and older are allowed in, however the show is recommended for ages 6 and up.
Theater: New Amsterdam Theatre – 214 West 42nd Street, New York, NY 10036
Wicked
Since it’s the pre-story to The Wizard of Oz, it’s ideal that you’ve all seen the film to understand plot points and some jokes, but overall you won’t be too lost if you haven’t seen the movie.
I’ve seen Wicked a handful of times, including the first year it came out with the original cast, and most recently in 2019, and the shows held up beautifully.
Since then, we’ve all become obsessed with the films, but nothing will truly ever measure up to how magical it is seeing Elphaba fly on Broadway.
Seating Tip: The Gershwin is quite large, but even at the back of the orchestra I’ve had a spectacular view.
Run Time: 2 hours and 45 minutes, including one intermission
Age Restrictions: Kids under 5 won’t be allowed in the theater, though the recommended age is 8 and up.
Theater: Gershwin Theatre – 222 West 51st Street, New York, NY 10019
&Juliet
Imagine if Juliet’s tragic tale took a turn towards empowerment and joy.
This is the heart of &Juliet, a vibrant retelling packed with modern-day hits.
It’s a jukebox musical with classic hits and a narrative everyone in your family will recognize. This show is perfect for families with tweens and teens, or anyone who just wants to go have some fun.
Seating Tip: I don’t think there’s a bad seat in the house for this show. I’d go with whatever I could afford.
Run Time: This show runs 2 hours and 40 minutes, with one intermission.
Age Restrictions: Recommended for ages 8 and up.
Theater: Stephen Sondheim Theatre – 124 West 43rd Street, New York, NY 10036
Harry Potter and the Cursed Child
If you’re a Harry Potter fan or have someone in your party who is, this is the show to see.
The story-line follows the children of the original characters as they have their own adventures at Hogwarts.
Cursed Child is absolutely magical and will leave even people who aren’t big HP fans in awe. As a massive Harry Potter fan, you know I was at one of the very first previews with my bestie, Jon, and we both were in awe of how well executed some of the effects are.
Even as industry folk, we couldn’t figure out how they pulled a few of the scenes off so seamlessly.
Sadly, since COVID, they’ve shortened the Broadway version of this show from being a two-part show into just one single show. I haven’t seen it since, but my bestie has, and said it was disappointing the condensed the show for Broadway, and it’s lots some magic.
However, if you’ve never seen the original, I hear Harry Potter fans, still absolutely adore this condensed version.
For super fans who do want to see the full show in all it’s two-part glory (as it was intended by the authors), head to the West End in London, where it’s still playing in two pieces.
Seating Tips: As much as I adore the mezzanine, this is one show where being in the orchestra adds a bit of extra magic (you’ll understand why when you go).
Run Time: Three and half hours with one intermission
Age Restriction: Recommended for children age 8 and up. An adult must accompany kids under 15.
Theater: Lyric Theatre – 214 West 43rd Street, New York, NY 10036
TodayTix
Book a Show!
Besides offering great prices, TodayTix also offers rushes and lotteries helping you score amazing deals on last minute tickets to some of the hottest shows in town!
If you click this link and make a purchase, I earn a commission at no additional cost to you.
Best Shows on Broadway for Adults
Two Strangers (Carry a Cake Across New York)
Two Strangers (Carry a Cake Across New York) is one of the most joy-filled Broadway experiences I’ve had in ages. I truly cannot remember the last time I laughed this much during a show, and my mom felt the same way. It’s heartfelt, funny, grounded, and performed with so much sincerity that it stays with you long after curtain call.
Everything about it feels intentional: the minimalist set design that lets the writing breathe, the incredible performances, the thoughtful pacing, the humor… even the fortune cookies waiting outside the Longacre Theatre feel perfectly on theme.
A relentlessly optimistic Brit arrives in NYC for the wedding of the father he’s never met, and a no-nonsense New Yorker has the task of picking him up from the airport. What follows is a chaotic, warm, and surprisingly emotional weekend full of errands, secrets, humor, and second chances. It’s truly a story that reminds you why New York feels magical in the first place.
This show is pure charm. I honestly see it being a real Tony Awards contender this season (I’m calling it now, alongside Titanique, which I’ve been obsessed with since off-Broadway).
Seating Tip: I saw this show from the mezzanine in the center, about six rows back, and had a wonderful view. They do sell box seats, however, those seem like they could be partial view at moments.
Truly, no matter where you sit, I think you’ll have a great view the way this musical is staged.
Run Time: Two Strangers runs 2 hours and 15 minutes, including one intermission.
Age Restriction: This musical is recommended for ages 12 and up.
Theater: Longacre Theatre – 220 West 48th Street, New York, NY 10036
Just In Time
Just In Time is an juke-box musical that I absolutely adored!
I caught a matinee on a snowy day and had an unforgettable experience learning about the legendary Bobby Darin (think “Beyond the Sea,” “Mack the Knife,” and “Splish Splash,”). Jonathan Groff shines in this role, bringing his Tony Award-winning talent to the stage once again.
And with Jeremy Jordan set to take over soon, the excitement continues (he’s fantastic in every show I’ve seen him in). If you’re looking for a biographical musical that captivates from start to finish, this is the perfect matinee choice.
Seating Tip: The biggest thing to know with this show is that performances begin promptly. There’s no late seating. People who leave their seat during the performance will not be allowed back in.
That said, I saw this show from standing room (thanks, to scoring a last-minute rush ticket), and had a great view. I’ve seen so many shows here over the years, and there’s truly not a bad seat in the house, because the entire venue is quite intimate.
Run Time: Approximately 2 hours and 15 minutes, with one intermission.
Age Restriction: Just In Time is best enjoyed by audiences aged 12 and up, as it explores the rich and sometimes mature themes of Bobby Darin’s life and career.
Theater: Circle in the Square Theater – 235 West 50th Street, New York, NY 10019
Operation Mincemeat
“Some were born to follow, but we were born to lead.”
After failing to snag a ticket to Operation Mincemeat on the West End in London last summer, thanks to its record-breaking awards sweep, and I was thrilled to catch one of its first Broadway previews.
This show is a British musical comedy that blends history, wit, and toe-tapping tunes into an unforgettable theatrical experience. I had such a fun night when I went during previews.
Curious about the plot? In short, it’s the true story of how MI5 agents pulled off an elaborate deception to trick Hitler during WWII, all told with music, humor, and a whole lot of charm.
Seating Tip: The Golden really has pretty fantastic views from every level. Personally, I’m a Front Mezzanine girlie until the end, so that would be my recommended spot if your budget allows.
The good news is most of the action is central, so even in the balcony, you’ll have a good view.
Run Time: Operation Mincemeat runs 2 hours and 35 minutes, including one 20 minute intermission.
Age Restrictions: I’ve seen one popular site recommended this for ages 5 and up, and honestly I wonder if they’ve even seen this show.
My nephew is 7 and some of the talk about war and dead bodies would easily give him nightmares.
Use your own judgement, but I’d recommend this for at least 13 and up. Children under 4 won’t be admitted (for good reason).
Theater: John Golden Theatre – 252 West 45th Street, New York, NY 10036
Death Becomes Her
Death Becomes Her is a musical adaptation of the cult classic 1992 dark comedy film, that’s campy, and massively entertaining…and you’ll be laughing from start to finish (at least I was!).
This musical delves into themes of vanity, rivalry, and the quest for eternal life, all while delivering a mix of dark humor and dazzling performances.
With its captivating story-line, memorable characters, and stunning musical numbers, Death Becomes Her is one of the best choices you can make if you want to just have a fun night at the theater (my friends have gone back multiple times).
Seating Tip: I really think anywhere in the Lunt-Fontanne Theatre is solid for this show.
Run Time: This show is 2 hours and 30 minutes, with one intermission.
Age Restrictions: Recommended for ages 12 and up.
Theater: Lunt-Fontanne Theatre – 205 West 46th Street, New York, NY 10036
Chicago
Not gonna lie, it took me ages to Chicago, but once I was there, I had the best time!
The part of Roxie Hart is constantly rotating between celebrities and just genuine triple threats, so it may depend on who’s in the cast when you go, but so far none of my theater friends ever complain about a weak performance from this show.
This show is a great date night choice, or last-minute snag at TKTS.
Seating Tip: There isn’t a bad seat in this house. I’ve seen this show from both the back of the Orchestra, and in the Premium Orchestra. Both views were excellent! Friends have told me the Mezzanine is also a solid a choice.
Run Time: 2 hours and 30 minutes, including one intermission.
Age Restrictions: Kids under 4 won’t be admitted, but let’s face it, this show is more of a PG-13 vibe.
Theater: Ambassador Theatre – 219 West 49th Street, New York, NY 10019
Hadestown
Hadestown isn’t for everyone, but it’s one of my favorites from the season it opened (it also won the Tony that year).
If you want to see a unique show, based on Greek myth of Orpheus and Eurydice, with hauntingly beautiful music, this is the show for you.
It’s a really great date night show, so if you’re looking for something romantic to do in New York, this might be it.
Local’s Tip: The bathroom line gets long here. I always run outside and across the street to the bar. They’re great about letting you order a drink while you run to the bathroom.
It’s a win-win. You get a bathroom with no line and a cheaper cocktail than you’d have had at the theater. Just keep track of time so you don’t miss the beginning of the first act.
Seating Tip: I’ve seen this show from both the rear orchestra and front mezzanine. Front mezzanine wins hands down!
Run Time: 2 hours and 30 minutes, including one intermission.
Age Restrictions: Leave anyone 4 and under at home. I’d say bring age 10 and above.
Theater: Walter Kerr Theatre – 219 West 48th Street, New York, NY 10036
Ragtime
Ragtime is a powerful and moving musical that has returned to Broadway, bringing its timeless story and unforgettable music to a new generation of theatergoers.
While I haven’t had the chance to see this production yet, it comes highly recommended by friends who were deeply moved by its compelling narrative and stunning performances.
Set in the early 20th century, Ragtime weaves together the stories of three diverse families, a wealthy white family, a Jewish immigrant father and his daughter, and an African American couple, whose lives intersect in surprising ways.
The musical explores themes of hope, change, and the American dream, set against the backdrop of a rapidly changing society. With a breathtaking score by Stephen Flaherty and Lynn Ahrens, and a book by Terrence McNally, Ragtime features iconic songs like “Wheels of a Dream,” “Your Daddy’s Son,” and “Make Them Hear You.”
Seating Tip: For the best experience, I recommend orchestra seating. It offers a close view of the intricate staging and the emotional performances that drive the story.
Run Time: 2 hours and 55 minutes, with one intermission.
Age Restrictions: Ragtime is best suited for ages 12 and up due to its mature themes and complex narrative. Children under the age of 5 are not permitted.
Theater: Vivian Beuamont Theatre – 150 West 65th Street, New York, NY 10023
Moulin Rouge: The Musical
If you’re looking for a really fun night out, head to Moulin Rouge. It’s a bit different than the film, but just as extravagant and fun.
Get there early to check out the pre-show dancing.
This is a great date night show, or one to do for a girls’ night. I’d avoid seeing it with family, just because it’s obviously a sexy show, and you don’t want to kill the vibe wondering how the jokes are landing with your parents.
Seating Tip: I saw this show from the rear mezzanine and had a wonderful view. I really don’t think there’s a bad seat in the house for this one!
Run Time: 2 hours and 45 minutes, including one intermission.
Age Restrictions: This a PG-13 type of show, though the official policy is that anyone under the age of 4 won’t be admitted.
Theater: Al Hirsheld Theatre – 302 West 45th Street, New York, NY 10036
Hamilton
Hamilton created a cultural phenomenon back in 2016 when it transferred to Broadway after playing to sold-out crowds Off-Broadway at The Public Theater.
These days, tickets are easier to come by, but you’ll still want to book tickets ahead of time to guarantee being in the “room where it happens.”
If you’re willing to risk it, play the daily lottery for your chance to win $10 front row seats.
Fair warning though, it’s a hard one to win.
Back when the show first transferred, it took me about six months of playing pretty much every single day to finally win.
It was totally epic, because it was right before it won all the Tony Awards that year, and I got to see the original cast.
Since then, I’ve been back to take my mom to see it, and even though it’s not the original cast, it’s still a phenomenal show.
In fact, I actually preferred the actor who played Burr the second time around. He found depth in places that hadn’t been so well explored the first time I saw it.
Seating Tip: I’ve seen this show from both the front row lottery seats, and the back of the premium orchestra section.
Both views were fabulous. The main thing I’d aim for here is being on an aisle.
The bathrooms at this theater are quite small, so the line builds up fast!
Run Time: 2 hours and 55 minutes, including one intermission.
Age Restrictions: Even though kids over 5 are allowed in, this is another show I’d recommend for at least age 10 and up.
Theater: Richard Rodgers Theatre – 226 West 46th Street, New York, NY 10036
MJ: The Musical
This show follows Michael Jackson during the creation of his 1992 Dangerous World Tour, and is meant to be fantastic.
MJ is currently at the top of my Broadway wish list for when I return to the city from Europe.
All my friends said the performers and choreography have blown away them.
Seating Tip: Go for the mezzanine for this show in order to fully appreciate the magnificent choreography.
Run Time: 2 hours and 30 minutes, including one intermission.
Age Restriction: The show is suggested for ages 8 and up, kids under 4 won’t be admitted.
Theater: Longacre Theatre – 220 West 48th Street, New York, NY 10036
The Book of Mormon
With Matt Stone and Trey Parker of South Park fame as its creators, it’s no wonder that The Book of Mormon is still one of the funniest shows on Broadway.
Basically, the show follows two naïve Mormon boys as they’re sent to Africa to convert the locals to Mormonism.
This show isn’t for anyone who takes offense easily.
I was invited to one of its early preview performances when it first came to Broadway and the entire row in front of me left mid-performance because they were offended by one song in the first act (when you see it you’ll know which one).
Since then, I’ve been back two other times, and the show still is just as funny as when it opened.
It’s still one of my favorite choices when I’m taking out-of-town friends to see their first Broadway show.
Seating Tip: Like most shows, I’m all about the front mezzanine, though the front bit of the rear mezzanine also has a magnificent view.
Run Time: 2 hours and 30 minutes with no intermission.
Suggested Age: This is definitely a PG-13 level show, though officially anyone over the age of 4 is allowed.
Theater: Longacre Theatre – 220 West 48th Street, New York, NY 10036
Maybe Happy Ending
This intimate and hauntingly beautiful new musical is the winner of a couple Tony Award honoring of Best New Musical
I haven’t had the chance to see this yet, as other shows took priority for me while I was in town last between travels.
What I do know is if you’re looking for something unexpected, poignant, and unlike anything else currently playing in NYC, add Maybe Happy Ending to your list.
My Broadway bestie tells me this is a quiet powerhouse of a production that deserves to be experienced.
Seating Tip: I’ve heard this is one show you really want to sit as center as possible for between the way the show is staged and the layout of The Belasco.
It’s also important to make sure when buying if you’re in the balcony or mezzanine that you don’t have tickets marked “partial view”, as apparently even some central seats in these sections aren’t great with the staging.
Run Time: This show runs 100 minutes, with no intermission.
Suggested Age: Recommended for ages 10 and up. Children under the age of 4 are not permitted.
Theater: Belasco Theatre – 111 West 44th Street, New York, NY 10036
The Outsiders
The Outsiders on Broadway is a Tony Award-winning stage adaptation of S.E. Hinton’s classic novel, which also inspired the beloved 1983 film.
If you’re unfamiliar, here’s what you need to know.
The centers on the lives of the Greasers and the Socs, two rival teenage gangs in the 1960s, delving into themes of friendship, loyalty, and social class conflict.
Evocative music, dynamic choreography, and a vividly evocative set design enrich the production, despite its gritty story-line.
Whether you’re drawn by the nostalgia or the powerful narrative, The Outsiders is sure to leave a lasting impression, just like it did when Tony voters gave it Best New Musical in 2024.
Seating Tip: This is one show you don’t want to be on the extreme sides, or up too close for.
Run Time: The Outsiders runs 2 hours and 30 minutes, including one intermission.
Suggested Age: Recommended for ages 10 and up. Children under the age of 4 are not permitted in the theater.
Theater: Bernard B. Jacobs Theatre – 242 W 45th St, New York, NY 10036
Six: The Musical
I saw Six on the London’s West End, but assuming the Broadway version is similar, this is a fun and quick show to catch.
It follows the six ex-wives of King Henry VIII as they take the audience through their lives and relationship with the King via several catchy pop songs.
It’s not something I’d spend a ton of money to see, but if you can score an affordable ticket, it’ll make for a fun night that leaves at least one song stuck in your head.
Seating Tip: Go for either front mezzanine or orchestra for this show.
Run Time: 80 minutes, with no intermission.
Suggested Age: Recommended for ages 10 and up. Children under the age of 4 are not permitted.
Theater: Lena Horne Theatre – 256 West 47th Street, New York, NY 10036
The Great Gatsby
The Great Gatsby on Broadway brings F. Scott Fitzgerald’s iconic novel to life with a fresh and dynamic stage adaptation.
The production captures the essence of the Roaring Twenties, complete with lavish sets, stunning costumes, and a jazz-infused score that transports audiences to the opulent world of Jay Gatsby.
The show delves into timeless themes of love, ambition, and the “American Dream”, making it both a visually and emotionally captivating experience.
For fans of the novel and newcomers alike, this adaptation offers an interesting and immersive journey into one of literature’s most enduring stories.
With its blend of dramatic storytelling and spectacular theatrical elements, The Great Gatsby on Broadway is certainly worth seeing for its ability to enchant and resonate with audiences.
Seating Tip: I’d go Front Mezzanine for this show, but there really isn’t a bad seat in the house.
Run Time: Approximately 2 hours and 30 minutes, including one intermission.
Suggested Age: Recommended for ages 10 and up. Children 5 years of age and above are permitted but must have their own ticket.
Theater: Broadway Theatre – 1681 Broadway, New York, NY 10019
Oedipus
Oedipus has returned to Broadway, offering a gripping and intense retelling of the classic Greek tragedy. I had the chance to see it last week and absolutely loved it. I highly recommend catching it if you get the chance before it closes next month.
Starring Mark Strong and Lesley Manville, this Broadway transfer of Robert Icke’s modern take on Sophocles’ tragedy is nothing short of spectacular. Set on election night, with the polls predicting a landslide victory, everything is about to change.
Director Robert Icke transforms Sophocles’ epic tragedy into an essential, explosive, and sensual human thriller, catapulting the secrets of the past into a high-stakes present.
Oedipus tells the story of the tragic king of Thebes, who is fated to fulfill a harrowing prophecy that he will kill his father and marry his mother.
This production brings a fresh and modern perspective to Sophocles’ timeless tale, exploring themes of fate, identity, and the inescapable nature of destiny. With a compelling script and a talented cast, Oedipus promises to be a thought-provoking and unforgettable theatrical experience.
Seating Tip: For the best experience, I recommend orchestra seating. It offers a close view of the intense performances and the intricate details of the staging.
Run Time: 2 hours, with no intermission.
Suggested Age: Recommended for ages 16 and up.
Theater: Studio 54 – 254 West 54th Street, New York, NY 10019
Titanique
Prepare for an unexpected twist on a classic tale as Titanique sails triumphantly from it’s hit off-broadway run to Broadway.
Opening later this year, this Celine Dion/Titanic parody boasts heart-stopping anthems leading this inventive spoof, to be a voyage you won’t soon forget.
I seriously can’t remember the last time I’ve laughed so much at a show. Don’t miss the boat on one of the shows who will absolutely be an eventual Tony nominee (and likely winner in at least a few categories – I predict it’s this or Two Strangers for Best Musical)
Seating Tip: I don’t think there’s a bad seat in the house for this show. I was able to get great seats through TodayTix about a week before the show.
Run Time: 1 hour and 40 minutes, with no intermission.
Suggested Age: I’d say PG-13, since it’s based on the film and there’s sexual innuendo, adult humor, and language.
Theater: St. James Theatre – 246 West 44th Street, New York, NY 10036
Chess: The Musical
Chess: The Musical has made its way back to Broadway, and while I haven’t had the chance to see it yet, friends of mine have experienced it firsthand. They mentioned that although they didn’t absolutely love it, they agreed it’s the best version of this musical they’ve seen put on.
Set against the backdrop of the Cold War, Chess: The Musical tells the story of a complex love triangle between two grandmasters, an American and a Russian, and the woman who manages one and falls in love with the other.
With a score by ABBA’s Benny Andersson and Björn Ulvaeus, and lyrics by Tim Rice, the musical features iconic songs like “One Night in Bangkok,” “I Know Him So Well,” and “Anthem.” This production brings a fresh energy and perspective to a classic, making it a must-see for both longtime fans and newcomers.
Seating Tip: I don’t think you can really go wrong if you can score a ticket to this hot musical.
Run Time: Chess runs 2 hours and 40 minutes, including one intermission.
Suggested Age: Chess: The Musical is best suited for ages 12 and up due to its mature themes and complex narrative. Kids under the age of 4 will not permitted.
Theater: The Imperial Theatre – 249 West 45th Street, New York, NY 10036
Best Off-Broadway Theaters to Keep an Eye On
Since the shows running Off-Broadway are constantly changing, it’s best to keep an eye on the schedules for these theaters and production companies.
I’ve been seeing shows at these spots for the last decade, and in some cases prefer their selection to what ends up on Broadway.
- The Public Theater
- St Anne’s Warehouse
- The Park Avenue Armory
- 54E59
- Cherry Lane Theater
- Minetta Lane Theater
- Company XIV
- Punchdrunk
Company XIV
Check Performance Schedule
After seeing Company XIV's amazing production of Seven Sins, I'm dying to catch their other productions. If it's as sexy as the last one I saw, you're in for one very steamy date night.
Use code ALLYTRAVELS and receive 20% off ticket prices!
If you click this link and make a purchase, I earn a commission at no additional cost to you.
Some of My Favorite Off-Broadway Picks
Masquerade
If you’re looking for a truly unforgettable theater experience, Masquerade, which is basically an immersive Phantom of the Opera, is an absolute must-see. This show is hands down my favorite thing I’ve seen in years, and it’s the perfect blend of drama, mystery, and immersive storytelling.
Unlike anything else, Masquerade pulls you into the world of the Phantom in a way that’s both thrilling and enchanting.
Yes, the tickets are on the pricier side, but trust me, it’s worth every penny. The production values are top-notch, and the way the show engages the audience is nothing short of magical.
The show transports you into a different world from the moment you step into the venue, and meticulous craftsmanship enhances every detail of the experience.
One thing that makes this show feel extra special is the dress code. Everyone dresses up, which adds to the sense of occasion and makes it feel like a truly special night out. If you’re a fan of unique and immersive theater, Masquerade is an absolute gem that shouldn’t be missed.
Also, this show is incredibly strict about the name on the tickets matching the name of the person picking the up, so don’t buy secondhand. You’ll also need a password that’s emailed to you about 24 hours before the show.
Seating Tip: Masquerade is a journey across multiple floors, so the great thing about this, is that everyone has a great view. I’d recommend trying to stay at the front of the group, but there’s really not a bad view.
Run Time: Masquerade runs about 2 hours, with no intermission. But keep in mind, you’ll likely want to hang out in the Phantom’s Liar bar area after. It’s such a scene, and the merch and bar is great. It almost feels like being in a trendy club downtown. I wish more theaters had lounges like this for after the show. It was so much fun talking with everyone, hearing what they thought of the show.
Age Restrictions: All guests must be at least 13 years of age and those under 16 must be accompanied by an adult at all times.
Theater: Lee’s Art Shop – 218 West 57th Street, New York, NY 10019
Heathers
Heathers: The Musical Off-Broadway is an absolute blast and a must-see for anyone looking for a campy, hilarious night out. I had so much fun at this show, even though I had never seen the movie.
I was dying of laughter throughout the performance. This show is truly iconic and perfect for older teens or anyone who appreciates a darkly comedic, over-the-top musical experience.
Set in the halls of Westerberg High, Heathers follows the story of Veronica Sawyer, a high school misfit who suddenly finds herself part of the most popular clique in school…the Heathers.
But things take a dark turn when Veronica meets the mysterious new kid, J.D., and together they embark on a twisted mission to take down the tyrannical Heathers. With its catchy songs, sharp wit, and satirical take on high school life, this show is a wild ride from start to finish.
Seating Tip: Pretty much anywhere in New World is going to be a full view since this off-broadway theater is fairly small. When I saw it, I was in the orchestra and had a great view.
Run Time: Heathers runs 2 hours and 30 minutes, with one intermission.
Age Restrictions: Just like the film, this show is for ages 14 and up.
Theater: New World Stages – Stage One – 340 West 50th Street, New York, NY 10019
BATSU!
BATSU! in New York is a unique and exhilarating live comedy show that offers an unforgettable experience blending elements of Japanese game shows with improv comedy.
Set in an intimate venue, the show features a cast of talented comedians who compete in a series of outrageous and often hilarious challenges, with the added twist of facing comedic punishments for failing tasks.
Plus, the interactive nature of the show ensures that no two performances are the same, making each visit a fresh and exciting adventure.
For those looking for a night of laughter and unpredictability, BATSU! is definitely worth seeing.
Its high-energy performances, audience participation, and outlandish humor create an engaging atmosphere that keeps everyone entertained from start to finish.
Whether you’re a fan of improv, intrigued by Japanese game show antics, or simply in search of a fun and unconventional night out, BATSU! promises a memorable and wildly entertaining experience.
Seating Tip: The show is set in an intimate venue, so you should be good no matter where you sit.
Run Time: Since every show is different, the timing varies a bit, but you can expect the show to be wrapping up roughly 2 hours from reservation time.
Age Restrictions: You must be 21+ to drink or sign up for a chance to participate in BATSU! We recommend that you be at least 18 years old to attend the show – no one under 16 will be admitted.
Theater: 67 1st Ave, New York, NY 10003
Little Shop of Horrors
At Westside Theatre, Little Shop of Horrors resurrects a cult favorite with a carnivorous twist.
This revival has laughs, thrills, and that iconic, sinister plant.
It’s the perfect fun night out solo, with friends, or with a date.
The great news is that because it’s been running a few years, it’s a lot easier to get into at the last minute.
Seating Tip: My ex and I saw this from premium orchestra which was amazing. It’s a small enough theater that I don’t think you can go wrong anywhere.
Run Time: This musical runs 2 hours and 15 minutes, including one intermission.
Age Restrictions: Children under the age of 4 are not permitted. Recommended for ages 8 and up.
Theater: Westside Theatre Upstairs – 407 West 43rd Street, New York, NY 10036
The Play That Goes Wrong
The Play That Goes Wrong is a hilarious British farce that follows an amateur theater group’s disastrous attempt to put on a murder mystery play.
Chaos ensues from the very beginning, with collapsing sets, missed cues, and increasingly absurd blunders that have audiences roaring with laughter.
Seating Tip: Anywhere you sit in this theater should have a good view.
Run Time: The play runs 2 hours, including one intermission.
Age Restrictions: Children under the age of 4 are not permitted in the theater. Recommended for ages 8 and up.
Theater: New World Stages – 340 West 50th Street, New York, NY 10019
FAQ’s
How do I choose the best seats at the theater?
A lot of the time, seating really comes down to personal preference and affordability.
I love being in the front mezzanine because it’s generally the best way to view the production as a whole, since you can get a clear view of the choreography, staging, and set design.
How to get cheap Broadway tickets?
Broadway shows tend to be quite expensive, so if you want to see a popular show book early on the show’s official website (never through Broadway.com) to score tickets in the cheapest section.
If you’re last minute, try playing the shows lottery or rushing their show (depending on what their policy is).
For tips, check out my full article on how to score the cheapest tickets to Broadway shows.
How far in advance should I get to the theater?
Since your seats are reserved, there’s no reason to get to the theater super early. Doors open 30 minutes prior to a production, and I’ll normally aim to arrive about fifteen minutes before the show starts. This way I can hit the bathroom, grab a drink if i want one, and settle into my seat without a big wait for the show to start.
What to do I wear to a Broadway Show?
These days, unless you’re going to an Opening Night, you can be fairly casual, though you’ll still want to look put together. Check out my article on “What to Wear to a Broadway Show” for all my tips and tricks to dress for a night at the theater.
Final Thoughts
I hope this has helped you find the best show on Broadway to see while you’re in NYC.
Since shows are constantly opening and closing, I’ll do my best to see as many as possible to keep this page as up-to-date as possible.
Let me know in the comments below if there’s a show I’ve missed that you think needs a mention on the list!
Recommended Reading
How to Get Discounted and Cheap Broadway Tickets in NYC
NYC is a expensive city, so you'll want to find discounts everywhere you go, including Broadway. These tips will help you find the best cheap Broadway tickets.
103 Best Things to Do in New York City: A Local’s Guide
Check out my ultimate local's guide to the best things to do in New York City. Including non-touristy things to do, it'll be a trip you won't soon forget.
25 Exciting Things to Do in Times Square at Night
Are you looking for something fun to do in Times Square at night? This list has ideas for tourists and locals, you just have to decide which option to do first!
31 Best Things to Do in Central Park: My Favorite Spots as a Local
Are you looking for unique things to do in Central Park? I've listed all my favorite spots, so follow my lead and you’ll have a perfect visit to the park.
53 Exciting Things to Do in NYC at Night: The City Made for Night Owls
New York City comes alive as darkness descends and the lights flicker to life. Check out my go-to list of things to do in NYC at night.
Leave a Comment